Regulated is not the same as safe

kameel baksh
Regulated is not the same as safe

Regulated is not the same as safe

Yesterday, the UK’s financial regulator opened the door.

Crypto firms can now apply to become fully authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority. It is a significant change. A category that has spent years somewhere between financial product, technology experiment and speculative asset is moving further inside the regulatory perimeter.

For consumers, that matters.

For marketers, something else happened too.

A new word became available. Regulated.

And that word is going to do a lot of work.

It will appear on websites. In advertising. In pitch decks. In app stores. In investor presentations. Somewhere, somebody is probably already deciding how close it can sit to a logo.

There is nothing inherently wrong with that.

Regulation should create trust. That is partly the point.

The problem begins when the meaning of the badge becomes larger than the
protection behind it.

The FCA provided an almost perfectly timed warning five days earlier.

It announced that 21 contracts-for-difference firms had closed following a crackdown, with another three cancelling their permissions. The concern wasn’t simply what the firms were selling.

It was how some were using their UK authorisation.

The FCA said firms carrying out little business in Britain had been using their authorised status to make linked overseas companies appear more trustworthy. A customer could reasonably believe they were dealing with a UK-regulated business, with UK protections, when the reality was more complicated.

Different product. Same marketing problem.

Direct investing has lived with a version of this for years.

In Canada, customers of regulated investment dealers can benefit from Canadian Investor Protection Fund coverage. That protection matters. But it has a boundary. It helps return eligible property when a member firm becomes insolvent. It does not protect an investor because a stock falls, an investment turns out badly or information was misleading.

The distinction is clear in the rules. It may be less clear in the customer’s head.

A regulatory status begins as a technical fact. Then marketing turns it into a signal. (Marketers: read that again).

And eventually the customer turns the signal into a story. Regulated becomes safe. Authorised becomes protected. Approved becomes recommended.

None of those translations is necessarily true.

This is where marketing in regulated industries gets interesting. The job isn’t simply to make complicated things easy to understand.

Sometimes the harder job is making sure something easy to understand
doesn’t become misleading.

The new UK crypto regime will introduce real protections. Firms will
have to meet standards around safeguarding, financial resilience, market
integrity and consumer protection. Authorisation won’t be automatic.

That should make the market better.

But it also makes regulatory status commercially valuable.

And whenever a piece of information becomes commercially valuable, there is pressure to stretch it.

Challengers will understandably want to say: you can trust us now.

Incumbents may want to say: we were trustworthy all along.

Neither is quite the point.

Trust isn’t created by the existence of a badge. It is created when the experience behind the badge consistently deserves it.

That means explaining which entity a customer is dealing with. Which activities are regulated. Which protections apply. Where they don’t. What can still go wrong.

Those details tend to disappear in marketing because they introduce friction.

Perhaps they shouldn’t.

In complex markets, clarity about the limits of a promise can be one of the strongest reasons to believe the promise in the first place.

The FCA is bringing crypto inside the regulatory perimeter. The marketing opportunity is obvious. The responsibility that comes with it should be too.

K Baksh


Sources: FCA - FCA opens the gateway to regulated crypto, 30 September 2026; FCA - Twenty-four CFD firms closing in crackdown on misuse of UK authorisation, 25 September 2026; Canadian Investor Protection Fund- About CIPF Coverage